Click to enlargeJ28/P6055

These coins were struck outside the mint originally by Joseph J. Mickley and Edward W. Cogan from dies sold by the mint as scrap. The obverse was from a reworked 1803 die, Sheldon 261 and the reverse is an 1820 Newcomb 12. These were created over several years with the dies wearing more and more over time.

Only 2 examples struck in tin are confirmed and both are illustrated.

1) Fewsmith (Mason & Co 10/1870), Jenks (Woodward 9/1880), Shinkle (Morgenthau & Co 4/1932), Sloss, B/M 3/97, Bird-Goldberg 2/20 - PCGS63, illustrated above, click on the thumbnail image to see an enlargement.

2) Superior's 5/2003 as PCGS62, SImpson-Heritage 11/20 - PCGS63, illustrated below.

These were listed in Judd because they were considered "off-metal" trials.

Examples were struck in copper and are listed as P6050 by Pollock. They are not listed in Judd. They are very common although red examples are scarce. These are normally collected by large cent collectors.

Additional information on these can be found in chapter 5 of Don Taxay's "Counterfeit, Mis-struck and Unofficial U.S. Coins" and also Mark Borckardt's article "Restriking the Issues: The Large Cent Restrikes of 1804, 1810, and 1823," Coinage of the Americas Conference, New York: American Numismatic Society, 1998."

Photos courtesy of I & R Goldberg Coins & Collectibles and Superior.